Toxic Methyl Bromide a health hazard
Essay by Hardy Ghost
"There they are. You can see the white spots on their heads and tails." Robert
Singleton points at the pale blue sky. A pair of Bald Eagles are circling between
his house and the next ridge north of him, about half a mile away. They came
back sometime during the last 20 years, he says. The majestic bird of prey has
been the national symbol of the United States for a long time. Once on the
verge of extinction because of pesticide use and hunting, its numbers have
increased, and the population seems stable and thriving again. They have also
found a home near Robert’s house, nestled in the forest of the Allegheny
mountains in Eastern Hardy County, WV. “We also have Golden Eagles, lots of
Wild Turkey, Black Bear, Raccoons, Opossums, and I even saw a Bobcat in my
front yard a year ago or so.” In this area, wildlife is thriving, there are springs and
creeks with clean water, and now in spring, with the forest waking up from
winter, the air is filled with scents of new life. An idyllic place away from noise
and pollution, a landscape that has not been touched by industry,
overpopulation, or climate change, nature’s refuge.
Singleton, a landscape painter who is nationally acclaimed, moved here 45 years
ago to escape the fast lane of life and find peace, live in nature, and clean air.
Since then, many more people have discovered the beauty of this place. They
have built cabins and homes in these woods, many of whom have moved here
permanently. Several National forests and protected areas in Eastern Hardy
County attract hikers, mountain bikers, kayakers, and nature lovers. Hunters,
out of the area and local alike, appreciate the richness of these woods flush with
deer and fill their freezers with game during the season. Organic farming has
been emerging in nearby Wardensville, where local youth learn to grow food,
treat land and soil with respect, as well business skills. But there is trouble
brewing in paradise.
On the next ridge, less than a mile northwest of Singleton’s residence, located at
Park Farm Drive between Baker and Moorefield, the company Allegheny Wood
Products International Inc. is planning to open a wood fumigation facility on the
grounds of an old poultry farm, which may be issued a permit by the Division of
Air Quality (DAQ) to emit up to 9.54 tons of Methyl Bromide per year as
determined by a preliminary evaluation.
Methyl Bromide, also known as Bromomethane, is a toxic, hazardous, ozone-
damaging gas that has been banned in most countries of the world and also
neighboring states like Maryland. It is strictly regulated and being phased out in
Virginia and North Carolina. The gas can harm human health, including
neurological, reproductive, respiratory, kidney, liver, and esophageal damage
and nasal lesions. While close proximity contact is the most dangerous, low-
dose exposure over longer periods can be harmful. Little to no regulation exists
regarding the protection of residents and the general public from the toxin in
ambient air, so of course, an Air Quality permit notice in the Moorefield paper
can state rightfully that “all State and Federal air quality requirements will be
met […]” because there are little to none. When you try and find more
information about it, the most puzzling fact may be that Methyl Bromide was to
be phased out completely in the US in 2017, “so why will we have to worry about
possibly inhaling it in a pristine natural environment like the one we live in
here?” asks a resident living close by. Furthermore, the toxin is subject to the
Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA), a federal law
designed to inform communities about planning efforts involving potential
chemical hazards on the state or local level.
Neighbor Neil Gillies, whose homestead is about a mile and a half from the
proposed facility, would like to know, “How in the world did an industrial facility
that will emit significant quantities of an extremely toxic gas go under the radar
and get to the point of receiving a provisional permit? Why have there been no
public hearings about this?” Pete Osinga “moved here for the clean air and
might have made a mistake.” His new house is less than half a mile to the
southeast of the site, and he may bear the brunt of chronic low-dose exposure
since winds mostly come out of the west and northwest and may carry
Bromomethane released by the company onto his property. Other folks from
the larger Hardy community want to turn up at the next Planning Commission
meeting and object to this development. Still, there is also a feeling of being
powerless among some. One neighbor with a property adjacent to the site
shrugs his shoulders in despair. “Williams, the owner of this land, also sits on
the Planning Commission. You know how this county works.”
Indeed, when digging a little deeper, one can find articles about a huge Poultry
farm near Old Fields, WV, about 2 years back, having received permits against
the protest of local people and without the knowledge of the then President of
the County Commission, who “had no clue that there was even an application
submitted or approved.” The owner of the land for the proposed fumigation
facility turns out to be the same entity, having pushed for and now running a
Mega Poultry farm in this county. Back then, Johns Hopkins Center for a Livable
Future had sent the new Hardy County Planning Commission president a letter
pointing out risks. “We believe that expanding poultry operations in Hardy
County will create similar hazards as those observed on the Eastern Shore of
Maryland, marked by an increase of contaminants and risks to soil, air, ground,
and surface water quality and the health of Hardy County residents.”
There is a pattern emerging. The health of residents and the environment does
not seem to matter versus the mighty dollar, where there is little regulation and
oversight in rural areas. Local opponents of proposed projects that threaten to
endanger their well-being have no choice but to step into the ring against a
Goliath out of their weight class. How do you win a fight like that when the other
side is that well-organized and can seemingly bend the rules to their will?
Will landscape painter Robert Singleton have to resort to painting toxic clouds?
Will the Bald Eagle in this area survive Methyl Bromide, a chemical used in
pesticides for farming back in the day, after recovering? Will the indifference of
cold business practice win over the value of public health and nature still
unspoiled? There is also concern about the effects on livestock, with a small
poultry operation less than a mile from the fumigation site. Dennis Funk has his
cattle grazing just a few 100 feet over on a neighboring property throughout the
season. Will someone inform him about the potential hazard looming? Last but
not least, property values may drop in the immediate surroundings because
who would want to potentially buy a home and property with the outlook of
having hazardous gas dispersed over their heads?
Baltimore Harbor had an average amount of 26 to 37 tons of uncontrolled
annual emissions of Methyl Bromide before fumigation for export reasons
ended in the port around 2016, and the use phased out in the state of
Maryland. In comparison, that would mean that local neighbors, residents,
wildlife, and the environment may soon be subjected to the toxic emissions of
roughly a third of a Baltimore international port near Baker, WV.
“For now, all we can do is get organized and find out when the next Hardy
County planning meeting takes place and turn up in numbers!” Sue Ryan, who
lives in the county and would like to see air quality and the environment
preserved, is trying to stay positive and mentions how we can still write
representatives, start petitions and try to make our voices heard.
Right now, any resident can write a short letter of concern and send it by May
5
th
, 2023, to:
Steven R. Pursley, PE
WV Department of Environmental Protection
Division of Air Quality
601 57
th
Street, SE
Charleston, WV, 25304
If public interest is expressed significantly, a meeting will have to be held. This
arguably should be the case in any way due to the federal law of the Emergency
Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act. But as this written piece has been
trying to show, Hardy County, WV, seems to be off the beaten path in location
and when it comes to rules and regulations. Residents must be motivated to
speak up and participate in protests to keep Hardy County’s air clean.
Written by: Hardy Ghost
Links:
https://civileats.com/2021/04/07/a-huge-new-chicken-cafo-in-west-
virginia-has-stoked-community-resistance/
https://ncnewsline.com/briefs/thousands-of-people-live-near-log-fumigation-
operations-royal-pest-solutions-fined-for-methyl-bromide-emissions-violations/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
Bromomethane
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Planning_and_Co
mmunity_Right-to-Know_Act
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v
=B3jEoLO-yVk